Posted on November 20, 2026

Read Press Release: Asbestos Advocates Disappointed After Fifth Circuit Court Dismisses All Challenges to EPA’s Asbestos Rule 

On November 19, 2026, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals dismissed all challenges to EPA’s 2024 chrysotile asbestos rule citing a lack of legal standing. The Court did not address the merits of the arguments presented by industry, labor, and public health organizations, including those presented by the Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization (ADAO).

The ruling leaves EPA’s chrysotile asbestos part 1 rule intact but does not resolve the urgent need for comprehensive protections against all asbestos fibers and uses.

ADAO and its partners presented scientific and legal arguments that EPA’s 2024 rule, which addresses only chrysotile asbestos and six limited categories of ongoing use, is incomplete and inadequate. ADAO maintains that these limitations leave significant gaps in protection and that comprehensive asbestos prevention must address all six asbestos fiber types and all uses. However, the Court did not rule on the merits of these arguments.

Statement from ADAO Co-Founder and President Linda Reinstein

“Although ADAO presented substantial evidence supporting our legal standing, the Fifth Circuit dismissed all challenges for lack of standing without considering the merits. Thirty-five years after the Fifth Circuit overturned most of EPA’s 1989 asbestos ban, we are once again left with critical gaps in asbestos protections that leave Americans at risk. 

We presented compelling scientific and legal arguments that EPA’s 2024 rule, which only covers one of six asbestos fiber types and six limited categories of use, is incomplete and inadequate. The Court did not consider these arguments. This ruling is a setback, not the end of our fight.

Thankfully, the chrysotile asbestos ban remains intact, but it is not enough. Americans deserve comprehensive protection from all asbestos fibers and uses. This rule has significant gaps in it and that is why ADAO pursued a legal remedy in the first place. It is also why ADAO has continued to press Congress to address this issue and ensure all Americans are protected from all types of asbestos.

The science is clear. Congress must pass the Alan Reinstein Ban Asbestos Now Act (ARBAN) to establish lasting protections against all asbestos fibers and prevent future asbestos-caused diseases.”

ADAO extends its sincere gratitude to Bob Sussman for his exceptional legal work, leadership, and steadfast dedication throughout this important challenge. We also thank our public health partners, firefighter unions, physicians, scientists, and advocates whose expertise and commitment strengthened our case.

Read the Fifth Circuit’s November 19, 2026 ruling.

Onward. Together.

Linda